< Return to Communication Tech
Seeing Reason Tool: Communication Tech
Research and Presentation Plan Scoring Guide

Group Invention___________________________________________Date________________

 

 4

 3

 2

 1

Plan
I use a number of techniques to develop a workable research strategy:  

I brainstorm ideas and organize them visually in lists, outlines, webs, concept maps.  

I list key words and ideas.  

I identify sources of information (library card catalog and databases, Web resources, experts, community agencies).

I use some techniques to develop a workable research strategy. My research strategy is not yet adequate to allow me to do a quality job. I have not yet developed a research strategy.

 4

 3

 2

 1

Gather and Compare

I gather the most significant information from an extensive variety of sources.

I effectively connect complex information from various sources.

I sort and classify my information effectively.

I choose relevant information from a variety of sources.

I effectively connect information from various sources.

I sort and classify my information.

I choose general information from a variety of sources.

I partially connect the information from my sources.

I sort and classify my information with some consistency.

I choose insufficient information from a few sources.

I neglect ot connect the information from my various sources.

I don’t know how to sort or classify my information in a useful way.

 4

 3

 2

 1

Analyze

I examine the topic from multiple perspectives. I evaluate the reasoning, assumptions and evidence supporting each perspective.

I assess the reliability of all my sources (primary or secondary; fact or opinion; point of view; timeliness). There are no delays in the use of props or visual aids.

I examine the topic from multiple perspectives. I recognize logical errors and omissions, cause and effect, and points of agreement and disagreement.

I consider the reliability of my sources.

I present a few perspectives. I may consider points of agreement and disagreement.

I do not consistently look at the reliability of my sources.

I present my own perspective.  

I assume my sources are reliable

 

 4

 3

 2

 1

Synthesize

I present a breadth and depth of relevant, accurate information and concepts. The information focuses on problems or themes as opposed to facts and details only.

I provide a conclusion with clear convincing reasoning and evidence to support it.

I present relevant and accurate information and concepts. The information is based on fact and opinion.

I provide a conclusion with sufficient evidence to support it.

I present some information.  The information is a combination of fact and opinion, but is narrow in focus.

I provide a conclusion with some evidence to support it.

I present limited, simplistic information. It is based on my own personal knowledge.

My conclusion is muddled and I don’t support it with evidence.

 

 4

 3

 2

 1

Presentation Pre-Planning Scaffold or Storyboard Pre-planning demonstrates material has been planned in a logical and sequential order. 

Place holders for appropriate graphics are in place.
Pre-planning has been done. The material is planned in a logical order. 

Some place holders for graphics are in place. 

Some pre-planning was done but information was not organized in a logical manner. 

Difficult to transfer between planning and required material. 
No pre-planning for presentation was completed.
 Total Points:
       


< Return to Assessment Plan

< Return to Communication Tech



Contact Education ›


Terms of Use, *Trademarks and Privacy ©Intel Corporation